This is a picture of woman being beaten up by a mob as you can plainly
see. Her clothes have been torn by the mob as you can plainly see. Her name is Uma Khurana. She was a school teacher
till LiveIndia accused her of
running a sex-racket with school girls in a fake sting in August 2007. LiveIndia’s
editor at that time was none other than Sudhir
Chaudhary. The same guy has recently acquired more fame in the Jindal-Zee extortion sting. The fake
sting not only damaged Uma Khurana personally, professionally and socially but
also physically. She filed a case against LiveIndia but they may have settled
it out of court later. TV channels don’t seem to learn. Still, a certain form
of witch hunting continues on TV. This is now practiced in a much specialised
form by Arnab Goswami (AG) on TimesNow. Kicking and screaming,
interrupting speakers, badgering, often talking nonsense is an art that has
been taken to a different level by the extremely obnoxious AG. This is not so
when he does a one on one interview in his ‘Frankly Speaking’ where he appears to be far saner and civilised. So
it’s safe to assume that what happens on his NewsHour is a deliberate “show”. If Arnab thinks it’s a great
hit, he has to count as the biggest moron in news business.
The Witch-Hunter |
Don’t know if AG is imitating Keith Olbermann of MSNBC or Sean Hannity
of Fox. Throughout the last week or so AG has been carrying a series on Nitin Gadkari (NG) and his supposed fake
investors. Fair enough! It’s the way that the whole expose is being organised
each day as Part 1, Part 2… Part 14, Part 16, Part 19 (as of October 29), that
makes one wonder if there is more to it than just exposing NG. One did not see
such enthusiasm in exposing Robert Vadra,
Salman Khurshid. The enthusiasm has
to be journalistic and within levels of decency. Where the political aspect is
concerned, nobody has any doubt that NG has blundered. That the funding of NG’s
companies through allegedly fake investors is highly improper is not being
debated. Whether these are illegal or not is for an inquiry to decide.
For starters AG had Anjali Damania with her silly SMSes as allegations.
Then came another drama by Arvind
Kejriwal & Co. that the media called a “damp squib”. But Arnab’s
witch-hunt had actually started much before these events. He and TimesNow had started their inquiries into NG’s businesses early
in August 2012. So till such time Arnab got some documents he played up the
non-issues and when their allegations turned out damp-squibs he turned on to
NG’s companies. What he did is a must and should be done. But the way it is being
done smacks of a witch-hunt that seems to have a larger political objective.
The TimesNow reporters have been hounding NG like street dogs and have
been chasing him all over the place. From RSS headquarters in Nagpur to the
airport and chasing him like paparazzi. Those beat reporters should be as
ashamed of themselves as AG should be. Take a look at the pics from TimesNow
and also ABPNews. The reporters crowding all around NG and even making movement
difficult. This is not just for NG; these street dogs that pass themselves off
as reporters seem to think it is their birth-right to crowd individuals and
shove their mics and cameras into people’s faces and bodies. PCI and NBA should outlaw this and issue an advisory to keep a clear
distance of at least 6ft. from any individual the media wishes question. If
not, these cowardly dogs should be sent to the municipal pound and made to
spend a day with the dogs there to see how it feels.
And why are these TimesNow street dogs cowardly? Take a look at the
second pic. This is one from a video that TNow repeatedly showed where Robert
Vadra is getting into his car. Not one of the media dogs is anywhere near him.
He is protected by those SPG guards and no one dared get anywhere near him to
ask any question. So will these street dogs learn to respect individuals only
when there are SPG or police around? Or when they belong to the Queen’s family?
Same goes for the dogs from other channels. It is neither ethics nor
professionalism that is being demanded. It is simple common decency that you
don’t push and shove anyone, no matter what the issue is. And then AG demands
answers for the nation. Thank you Arnab,
obnoxious morons like you don’t need to speak for this nation!
That is one part of the story. Here is a tweet from the Monk. He
suggests it is tough to cover Congress for a reporter but BJP loves media.
Anyone who certified this guy a journalist should be stripped of his license to
be a journalism-school principal. If Rajdeep doesn’t know that Opposition
parties make their voices heard more through the media than govt voices then he
should quit and tend his dog. In fact the news media itself is supposed to play
an adversarial role to the govt of the day. On the contrary, our media seem to
be slaves and parrots for the govt. Here’s the worse part: Because the BJP is
more accessible for the media it seems Arnab and Rajdeep find cheap thrills in
frequently targeting them rather than the real criminals in the govt. What does
it say when post-release of the Jindal-Zee tapes Naveen Jindal goes on every news channel proclaiming his
“innocence”? Where’s further investigation in Coalgate and of Naveen Jindal’s
operations? And Jindal, the alleged coal-scammer, goes around certifying
Rajdeep and Arnab as journalists with great ethics. The height of insults that
Arnab can ever get is a comment, of all people, by a journalistic-bimbo who
posted this comment about him on Madhu Kishwar’s website:
Sagarika
Ghose, CNN IBN: Great piece on Arnab. He’s
dangerous for TV news. Not all of us are like that though!
Imagine, the Social Genius
of all people calling Arnab as “dangerous for TV”. Haha! That comment was in
response to a scathing open letter Madhu Kishwar wrote to Arnab sometime back.
(Read here). I also recommend
that he read all the comments in response to that letter to realise how he has
fallen in the eyes of viewers. So what makes AG behave in this fashion? Not
sure, but I imagine years of playing third fiddle to Rajdeep and Barkha Dutt at
NDTV could be one reason. The other
reason could be to gain TRPs over NDTV and CNN-IBN.
If that is true, then Arnab has to be pretty stupid. Any channel with decency
and a fair bit of news can score over both NDTV and CNN-IBN quite easily. The simple advantage Arnab has over some
other media celebs is nobody doubts his integrity. Not yet! But if he continues his theatrics and obnoxious
witch-hunts people will indeed start doubting his integrity too.
Even within the BJP there is a strong opinion that Nitin Gadkari should
resign. If not, he should definitely not be given another term as party
president. This is apart from the man and the party welcoming a full inquiry.
Arnab is within his rights to seek an inquiry. He has no moral right to
witch-hunt anyone. All the channels were quick to discuss the Jindal-ZeeNews
extortion episode. While that is a welcome change one wonders why they aren’t following
up with an investigation on Naveen Jindal. If Zee is alleged to have sought
payments for “silence” it does make me wonder if other channels have already
been paid in some form or the other for “silence”. Everyone observing news
channels was pretty clear that after the Robert Vadra and Salman Khurshid
episodes the channels would go after a BJP personality for ‘balance’ and that
would extend right till the HP and Gujarat elections. It does appear that Arnab
has chosen it upon himself to be that obnoxious witch-hunter. There’s more bad
news, Sunday Guardian even suggests
it’s an attempt to “Hammer Gadkari to save Vadra and other scamsters”
and I quote:
“Apparently, a strong word was conveyed that
they should leave Sonia Gandhi's son-in-law well alone. Ministers, including
I&B boss Ambika Soni, are said to have reached out to the media houses,
gently suggesting that further interest in the doings of Robert Vadra and his
multifarious business activities would be most unwelcome”.
None of this is lost on viewers and observers. There are some who
believe Arnab’s belligerent witch-hunt of Gadkari is over a petty issue of not
having got an interview like his close competitors did. Some believe what
Sunday Guardian suggests. Whatever the motivation, Arnab would do well to
control his belligerence on TV. He would do himself a lot of good if he treated his panellists and his targets with
a certain level of decency and respect and not with obnoxious witch-hunts.
There’s a 100 crore defamation suit against TimesNow; wonder what happened to
that.
Note: WitchHunter image from www.dakkadakka.com.. modified by @Udgeetha