Reservations were meant to last only 10 years but are now permanent in nature. It has now degenerated into “Casteist Politics” rather than uplifting anyone. PM Narendra Modi has turned out to be India’s worst Casteist and the Judiciary is not far behind in its rulings. This series is not so much about Reservation itself but about the bogus reasons and faulty logic employed by both, Modi and the SC, to enlarge this crime to unprecedented levels that are now irreversible. All the nonsense of “Soshit, Vanchit, Peedit” or “ancestors sinned” does not hold anymore. It is just criminal casteist, vote-bank politics and nothing else.
I write this in two parts as it’s a long-standing crime that even the judiciary has willfully condoned. I will debunk the rulings of SC in the recent NEET case which has poor, uneducated reasoning behind it as also Modi’s extreme hatred for upper castes which drive these monstrous discriminatory policies. First, let’s hear Modi’s deep grudge from stupid crap about sins by ancestors as he claims in this video (20 secs):
Modi refers to discrimination as “Paap” (Sins) of ancestors. Even assuming that is true, the reference he makes to the Anti-Hindu Ambedkar’s Reservation by Constitution was only meant for a decade. Obviously, Ambedkar didn’t have the foresight about the crime he was sowing and that the crime would be eternal in nature. Today, the “sins” are in reverse with the SC/ST Act and Reservations. This is not “Social Justice” or rehabilitation – This is pure and simple REVENGE driven. And Modi as the worst casteist seeks to obliterate upper castes while seeking to add Muslims, Christians to the kitty of backwards by his U-turn policies:
Muslims and Christians were already claiming Reservation benefits in many states. Under Modi, a clandestine operation has been put into motion. First, in August 2020 the M&C go to SC seeking benefits for their Dalits when their religion is supposedly caste-less. Then in February 2021 ModiSarkar grandly asserts Converted Christians, Muslims will not get quota. Come UP elections, in January 2022, the GOI reportedly mulls a Commission to examine SC status to M&C segments. These events are not coincidences; they are premeditated crimes to execute a policy that will legalise Reservations for M & C which was so far covert. Let us now look at the recent judgement of SC on Reservations and the deprived classes and competitive exams:
That is none other than Justice Chandrachud who likes to sermonize people as much as Modi does. His entire logic is faulty, without basic reason and will not stand the test of any scientific thinker on social issues. This is nothing but brazen, intelligent defence of the most craven caste politics. Everyone is shaped by their “lived experience” and social and cultural situation. And the statement that “merit cannot be reduced to narrow definitions of performance in open competitive exams” is horrendously wrong and flawed. The very meaning of “Competition” or “Competitive” is that everyone stands an equal shot at the trophy regardless of the person’s background or social advantages or disadvantages. Social disadvantages, if any, can and should be compensated ONLY at the basic qualifying level of school and college till the open competition.
Let’s say, in a 100-meter race of 20 students, if 10 are found to be physically weak because of their “Soshit, Vanchit” crap, you can give them nutrition, higher training than others to make them equal but what Modi and SC are doing is – In the REAL COMPETITIVE race, those 10 weak students will be given a 50% discount on timing by Modi and SC. So, if the regular student runs the race in 20 seconds and the weaker one runs the race in 38 seconds, the weaker one will be declared the winner because his run would be deemed to be in 19 seconds due to the 50% discount. That’s what this foolish Reservation does at the highest Competitive level. It’s a crime – Reservation can be to qualify to compete, Reservation cannot be for the results and the trophy. This is the crime Modi and SC are committing by declaring a loser the winner while the REAL winner might end up 12th in the race because of such idiotic logic.
It flies against the silly comments by SC and many other courts and the vengeful, anti-UC Modi that they fail to recognise that both backward classes and UCs commonly share poor economic conditions and social disadvantages imposed by the very govts that claim to help them. According to their moronic logic, the boy with 38 seconds timing should be sent to the Olympics and other international events. But it doesn’t work that way in sports or internationally. You cannot be anti-merit or have Reservations in sports. That is why India remains a laggard internationally on most parameters because the govts, judiciary and politicians are anti-merit. They are blind to the damage it causes the country. And then Modi barks about the fraudulent “Atmanirbhar” while imports from China were the highest in 2021.
Let’s take the “Soshit, Vanchit” nonsense of Modi. This may be valid for some monetary doles but not for “Competitive” events like qualifying exams. Modi and Judiciary have failed to understand and totally destroyed what “Competitive” means. Let’s take the US for example. Jesse Owens was a Black man or of African Origin. The Africans suffered humiliation, slavery, racial discrimination and not even voting rights during Owen’s time when he competed in the 1936 Olympics. That 1936 edition was held against the White Supremacist theory of Hitler. Owens was the 10th child of his family, his grandparents were slaves and cotton-pickers in farms. He won 4 golds, all in track & field events.
“Jesse Owens struggled to find work after the Olympics. He raced against horses for money and worked as a gas station attendant and a playground janitor. Using his fame to his advantage, Owens began working in public relations in the 1950s, traveling the country and making paid appearances at public events”. The Civil Rights Act of 1964 ended Black segregation and Owens lived a slightly better life but certainly not because of govt doles but by equality of Rights, including voting rights.
But the story is not just about Jesse Owens. Blacks and those of Africa have regularly been good at sprints and long-distance running. Kenya and Ethiopia have consistently produced winners. But even African origin athletes like Usain Bolt or Carl Lewis have excelled in running. It is not just genetics but their so-called “Lived Experiences”. How come “Lived Experiences” of these athletes make them champions but “Lived Experience” by description of J Chandrachud make them losers in India? Even the White Zola Budd of South Africa ran barefoot as did the Black Africans of Kenya and Ethiopia in their normal lives. This story of Blacks being great at running is explained scientifically in many articles including this one:
Just as the physical prowess of Africans is VISIBLE, the mental prowess of certain castes/groups is NOT VISIBLE. You cannot make Whites or Indians running champions by handicapping the African runners. That’s why the moronery of discrimination thinking “equality” can be established by mere Reservations. The relatively backward nations of Africa produce champions compared to more developed nations. India doesn’t even figure in it. In much a similar fashion, TamBrams are traditionally good at Math and Science because of their family practices, their devotion to Vedas and Hindu practices while other castes are good at business and trade. Would you send someone to Olympics instead of Bolt because he is backward or “Soshit, Vanchit”? NO! Then why would you send your worst to become doctors or scientists? Because “mental championship” is not as visible as physical prowess even though many results are indicative of that.
Modi and SC are irresponsible for the wrong reasons they claim for Reservations. Sundar Pichai lived in poor conditions like most Brahmins have in India. Businessmen like Dhirubhai Ambani have also lived in poor conditions. There are many stories like these. To claim “Lived Experiences” affect only the backward and enriches their merit is faulty and foolish. Every human has lived experiences and times have changed over decades.
Owens had a net worth of $1.5 lakhs at his death, Usain Bolt has a net worth of $90 million. If in 75 years the GOI, Judiciary and politicians have not been able to raise the standards of life of the Backward then their policies are foolish and wrong and a total failure. Reservation, in particular, has been a continuing failure and a crime against “Equality”. Reservation doesn’t further equality as SC claims, it promotes social disharmony, inequality and distress to the merited. Reservation does not promote equality, it is merely a political tool for brainless politicians who do not have any ideas or thoughts to bring progress for all. Modi, especially, a hollow hypocritical liar that once claimed “Justice for all and appeasement of none”. If Reservations are not legally possible, Modi has increased financial doles to Minorities (read Muslims). Consequently, they demand more and more doles as do farmers, backward classes, Gujjars, Patels, Christians and so on.
To be continued…
Subscribe Donate INR Donate Intl Cards
